I am no longer taking custom orders.

Make your memories sweeter.

Hi! I’m Jessica, owner and founder of Must Love Frosting, where everything is made with my signature buttercream frosting.

I am extremely passionate about the work I do. I put a lot of time and detail into every single baked treat I make to provide you with the best looking and tasting product possible!

I also love teaching people how to decorate with buttercream frosting, whether it’s just for fun or to advance their own baking business.

I have closed down taking any custom orders for my business for the foreseeable future.

Jessica Lutovsky Food Network

As seen on Food Network!

In December of 2022 I appeared on Food Network’s Christmas Cookie Challenge. I competed against four other incredibly talented bakers!

I was on Season 6, episode 6 “Wacky Christmas”

You can watch the episode on Discovery Plus!

Ree Drummond, Pioneer Woman, Food Network-

“This is one of the best cookies I’ve ever had”

Brenda K.-

“BEST COOKIES EVER! And they are decorated so well you almost hate to eat them!”

Lynette S.-

“Beautiful and delicious. What more could you want from a cookie?”

Sarah S.-

“Our son’s cake was above expectations! The flavors were amazing! Very moist! The outside of the cake was so perfect!”

 FAQs

  • When I’ve tried shipping in the past the buttercream designs haven’t arrived intact. I’d love to be able to ship some day, but currently I only do local orders.

  • Yes, I have a 1 dozen minimum requirement for regular cookies, and 2 dozen minimum for minis.

  • Check my availability calendar to see if I’m available for your date. For smaller orders (1-2 dozen), I need at least a few day’s notice. For larger orders I need at least a week or two to prepare.

    If my availability calendar shows that I’m booked and you’re in a bind, feel free to contact me anyways, sometimes I am able to squeeze in smaller orders!

  • Yes! However, because I use the same tools and equipment for all my baked goods I cannot guarantee there won’t be any cross-contamination.

  • After experimenting with different variations and brands of ingredients, I have perfected my super smooth and creamy American buttercream frosting. I use an all butter (no shortening) recipe which makes for a rich and creamy texture without leaving an oily aftertaste. I am happy to create any flavor of buttercream that you want! Some popular flavors are:

    -vanilla

    -chocolate

    -almond

    -confetti

    -lemon

    -strawberry

    -lavender

  • Unfortunately, I cannot discount my pricing. I spend quality time making sure each cookie is perfectly decorated so you can get the best-looking product possible.

  • I can take payment through the following platforms:

    -Venmo

    -PayPal

    -Zelle

    -Square (You can pay with your credit card for a 3% fee using this platform)

    Full payment is due at time of ordering to reserve your date and secure the order. I can offer a full refund for cancellations if given at least 1 week notice and 50% refund for 72 hour notice. I typically start working on your order at least a day or two in advance, so there are no refunds for no shows or short notice cancellations.

  • No, all orders are pick up only.